Citizen G'kar: Musings on Earth

September 01, 2005

Curing Health Costs: Let the Sick Suffer

New York Times
The word in Tennessee is that Gov. Phil Bredesen, a Democrat, has presidential aspirations. I find that interesting. Perhaps he can run on the success he's had throwing sick people off of Medicaid. Thanks to Mr. Bredesen's leadership, Tennessee is dumping nearly 200,000 residents, some of them desperately ill, from TennCare, the state's Medicaid program. Cindy Mann, a research professor and executive director of the Center for Children and Families at Georgetown University's Health Policy Institute, concisely characterized the governor's efforts:


"What he's decided to do is save health care costs simply by not giving people health care."


How's that for a solution to a tough public policy issue?
What is happening in Tennessee is profoundly cruel. The people being removed from the rolls - some of them disabled, some suffering from such serious illnesses as cancer and heart disease - are mostly working-poor individuals who cannot afford private insurance. They are being left with no coverage and in many instances are in a state of absolute panic.


"People are going to die because of this," said Carolyn Cagle, a widow from Paris, Tenn., whose 34-year-old son, Lloyd, is a diabetic who has already lost part of his right foot. He is being dropped from the program.


Phil Dedrich, a resident of Waynesboro, has also been notified that his coverage is ending. "I am very sick," he said in a statement distributed by opponents of the cuts. "I have severe coronary artery disease, including a 70 percent blockage of my aorta, lung disease, thyroid disease, diabetes, painful neuropathy from the diabetes and high blood pressure."

Of the 200,000 people dumped from public health insurance, how many do you suppose will die as a result? 1,000? I'd call that not a bad guess. Yet do you hear the hue and cry you hear about New Orleans?
Governor Bredesen may well have a viable presidential campaign, as a Republican. There is plenty of greed and Sunday Christians in that party.
MORE

No comments: