The Return of the Welfare Queen and Open Class Warfare

Michael Steele invoked class warfare in his fear mongering attempt to turn seniors against the working poor who can't afford health care by claiming the seniors will lose Medicare benefits if health care goes to the uninsured. This guy is as dishonest as anyone in the Republican Party.

Image by ajagendorf25 via Flickr

The healthcare reform debate took a rather remarkable turn last week when the Washington Post published an Op-Ed piece by Republican National Committee chairman Michael Steele telling retirees that his party would fight any effort to modify the benefits they derived from the government-run Medicare program in order to offer similar benefits to others. The Op-Ed was immediately supplemented by an item on the RNC Web page trumpeting a "Seniors' Health Care Bill of Rights," similarly pledging the GOP to a to-the-death defense of Medicare benefits and procedures, allegedly under dire threat from universal health coverage.Steele's gambit mainly got attention because it was laughably in conflict with nearly a half century of Republican attacks on Medicare, and because he adopted every ludicrous made-up claim about the impact of this or that health reform bill on Medicare. In a disastrous NPR interview later in the week, the GOP chieftain had a predictably difficult time explaining why the GOP wanted to "protect" Medicare because it was so bad a program that it couldn't withstand any "raids."

[..]This should be familiar to any political observer over the age of 30 as a new version of the old "welfare wedge": the emotionally powerful conservative argument that Democrats want to use Big Government to take away the good things of life from people who have earned them and give them to people who haven't.

[..]What's most interesting, and dangerous, about the new "welfare wedge" is that it's not about poor people who don't work for a living. After all, most very poor families often already have health insurance (depending on where they live) via Medicaid, and those who don't work these days generally don't have the option of working. The target of "welfare" shouters seems to be the working poor, or middle-class minority families who are struggling to stay in the middle class.

via The return of the welfare queen | Salon.

Related articles by Zemanta

• GOP Healthcare Plan: Delay, Obstruct, Lie, Rinse, Repeat (dailykos.com)


• Michael Steele On Medicare: "a very good example of what we should not have happen" (dailykos.com)


• Yuna Shin: Is Michael Steele's Position on Health Care Reform "Nuanced" or "Clear"? Answer: The New GOP Is the Old GOP. (huffingtonpost.com)


• Steele: 'The era of apologizing for Republican mistakes of the past is now officially over' (queerty.com)


• GOP accused of health 'fear-mongering' (msnbc.msn.com)


• NPR Slices and Dices Michael Steele (talkingpointsmemo.com)


• The Republican Party Left Arlen Specter (mydd.com)


• Steele Gets Testy With NPR: Says Reporter Is Doing "A Wonderful Little Dance" (huffingtonpost.com)


• Michael Steele On Medicare (newstalgia.crooksandliars.com)


• Cognitive Dissonance (talkingpointsmemo.com)

Talking Points for Healthcare Reform

Image via Wikipedia

1. When you need life-saving care, private insurance companies only profit by denying you and letting you die. If you have payed your premiums on time all your life, you're as likely to be dropped by your private insurance company when you need life-saving care as you are to get treated. A public option gives you a lifeline.

2. Private insurance companies are spending over $1M a day to kill the public option by inventing phony citizen groups, and trying to scare the elderly about euthanasia and pro-lifers with abortion; they know the only way to kill reform is to get people of good conscience fighting, while they laugh all the way to the bank. They don't think very highly of our intelligence.

3. We pay more than any other country to be 24th in life expectancy: while the average Canadian family spends less than $2000 a year on health care with no waiting periods, the average American family spends $29,000 a year, waiting for private insurance companies to approve every procedure.

4. 14,000 Americans lose their health insurance every day; 46M are uninsured.

5. 18,000 Americans DIE each year due to lack of health care: THAT'S 50 A DAY.

6. Two-thirds of American personal bankruptcies are related to health care costs.

7. Businesses - particularly small businesses - cannot afford to provide health insurance for their employees under the current employer based private insurance system, and will be forced to either drop their coverage or go out of business unless a public option is passed.

8. One-sixth of all our government spending is on health care, twice as much as any other country spends out of its budget. Our nation pays $2.5 trillion for care costing $912 billion .

9. Every independent estimate says the public option will save us money, from saving 150 billion dollars (CBO) to saving 265 billion dollars (Commonwealth). The Congressional Budget Office estimates the current bill in the House would leave a 6 billion dollar surplus.

10. So - if you'd rather spend more taxpayer money, bankrupt businesses, AND pay $29,000 a year for your family's private insurance coverage in exchange for a policy that can be dumped the second you actually need it, then the current system is great for you. If you'd rather spend less, wait less, have less of a chance of dying, and want to remove the corporate bureaucrat from between you and your doctor, then a public option is the way to go. Right now, even if you're lucky enough not to be dropped by your provider when you need urgent medical care, your private insurance company can overrule your doctor's advice for life-saving treatment and only offer to cover something cheaper; a public option would remove that middleman and leave these decisions where they belong, between the patient and doctor.

via Daily Kos: State of the Nation.

How can the richest people in the world allow millions to be homeless and without health care. Fifty American's die every day!

Related articles by Zemanta

• UnitedHealthcare of Ohio Inc. reported a second quarter profit of $859 million (dummidumbwit.wordpress.com)


• Obama discusses "health insurance reform" and small business (dailykos.com)


• Obama dispels "outlandish rumors" about health care reform (dailykos.com)


• Do Blue Dogs and Republicans Really Want to Be Remembered As People Who Sentenced 18,000 Americans Each Year to Die? (iflizwerequeen.com)


• Just Throw Grandma From the Train (crooksandliars.com)